It doesn't matter if I use single user, user list or database my site won't log in. I have done this successfully on another site so I don't know why this isn't working.

I currently have it set too authenticate from database. Why won't it authenticate? Always says it isn't the right credentials.

www.scriptclub.ca/index.php

Hello Brad,
When i load your page i see the following error message in the dev console of the browser.

POST dmxSiteSecurity.php
500 Internal Server Error
require_once(): Failed opening required '../ScriptLibrary/dmxSecurityProvider/dmxSecurityProvider.php' (include_path='.:/usr/php/54/usr/lib64:/usr/php/54/usr/share/pear')

Can you please check if the path is correct and if the file is uploaded?

Any idea why this would occur? Support at Bluehost is totally useless and doesn't even know what the developer console in the browser even is.

I fixed it ..... thanks! Seems to work now.

In case others have the same issue the problem seemed to be in the ScriptLibrary folder somewhere. I deleted it off the server and then uploaded it again and the error seems to have gone away.

As the error says, most probably this file was not uploaded to your server:
ScriptLibrary/dmxSecurityProvider/dmxSecurityProvider.php

It was uploaded but must have been an issue with it somehow as after I deleted it and re-uploaded it it began to work nicely.

Lovin' it! Now we just need a validation extension ;-)